The labels also state DISTRIBUTED BY THE KROGER CO, CINCINNATI, OHIO 45202. The FDA did not check that promise until 2006. An FDA report noted that company leaders thought sanitation problemswere to blame for the current contamination. Great to know, thanks! Amazon Elements is the brand. I figure, if the hospital uses only water on micro preemies, it must be the best thing. This is a real issue for my as 98% of Irish tap water is flouridated and this is potentially a hazard for our children. They sent the whistleblower letter to the FDA in October 2006. Please enable JavaScript to experience this websites full functionality. And then the question arises about whether such a small amount of benzalkonium chloride is enough to protect these wet wipes from growing bacteria and mold. Remedy: Immediately stop using the product and contact Wayne/Scott Fetzer Company d/b/a Scott Fetzer Consumer Brands for This report was originally published onDec. 27, 2011, as part of theseries "Shattered Trust.". "That is unusual and would likely be cause for heightened alarm at the agency," Crosse said. One can locate the lot numbers on the upper front portion of the box. I was just thinking the past couple days that my LOs skin was looking darker This recall does not affect other WaterBUG models. We promise not to send you any junk. What are your thoughts on using wipe warmers with Watervwipes? I'm so glad you're here! Thanks for your information. I was convinced by the company that their GSE (the only ingredient besides water) has no additives such as triclosan. However, all baby wipes must have preservatives because they are moist, and water is a potential breeding ground for bacteria and mold. Best Sellers Rank: #159,959 in Health & Household ( See Top 100 in Health & Household) #264 in Personal Cleansing Wipes. While the disposable wipes industry has grown rapidly, churning out everyday products that millions use in hospitals and at home, the nation's public health watchdog has not kept up. 155 Fleet Street, The FDA has not inspected several thousand drug and device makers in at least five years, and hundreds of plants have not seen an inspector in a decade. If the problems were serious, they said, the FDA would have taken action. When my baby was 3 weeks old and she had a really really bad diaper rash i had no idea what happened because we kept up on every diaper change and made sure i put cream right when i saw a red spot. Before commenting, please read our Comment Policy. I still remember the time when I did not know that I needed to read baby wipes ingredients. In other words, will what goes into the products get out of hand in more ways than one? But if you open the Q&A section today, you will not see this information there anymore. The FDA test of Rockline wipes revealed levels of a different bacterium,Burkholderia cepacia, that microbiologists interviewed by the Journal Sentinel called "gross contamination.". wipes were sold in the cleaning supplies section of stores instead of with the personal care and hand sanitizer products in the health and beauty aisle, the suit alleges. The patients immune system was suppressed by chemotherapy. I would just like to know what I should reach for next if my top pick isnt available when I need it. The study found benzethonium chloride, methylparaben, and triclosan in commercial products labeled as grapefruit seed extract. 3123. The poop being rubbed around the urethra in the diaper or with a wipe is much more of a risk than a non preserved wipe. So, it is a good thing that Costco baby wipes contain preservatives because they are all water-based. Do we know the concentration of this substance in the WaterWipes baby wipes? 2023 www.jsonline.com. I also want to be sure that the wipes will remain safe after opening as, after all, bacteria which is unseen can be so dangerous. I opened another packet and the same thing. This survey states that synthetic disinfectants such as benzethonium or benzalkonium salts were detected in most commercial GSE products. The Hartland-based Triad Group was raided by federal agents in April and recalled sterile alcohol wipes used in hospitals and other products. We promise not to send you any junk. The recalled products contain methanol, or wood alcohol, which can be harmful if absorbed through the skin or fatal if ingested. on Twitter: "Just Posting for Any Mommas Who May Not Have Seen- Parents Choice Wipe Recall ". There is some evidence that this well-known irritant may cause contact allergy even at concentrations as low as 0.1% (source). Managers said conveyors were not covered at other plants in the industry and refused. Jacques' case is pending. My conclusion got confirmed in a private consultation with a person experienced in microbiology. Recall While federal law does not set a maximum, the FDA has said a cosmetic should not contain an excessive level of bacteria. FDA records show the agency learned of the contamination from the whistleblower letter, and the FDA didn't know the company was doing a recall until its unannounced inspection. It is a disinfectant and can serve as an antimicrobial preservative in products. Wilson, 68, who worked at Rockline for 15 years, contended in his lawsuit that he was fired because he was a whistleblower and also because he was old. Claim: Several brands of baby wipes available in the U.S. were recalled in 2017 because they pose a risk of serious infection. Snopes and the Snopes.com logo are registered service marks of Snopes.com, Impacted lot numbers L22075 through L22085. Accessed 4 May 2022. He received $72,000 in back pay and insurance costs. Bathing a newborn baby: how & where to bathe a newborn baby. Nothing else has changed. The agency cannot order a recall of wipes - sterile or not. Recalls, Corrections and Removals (Devices). FDA, 17 Mar. Parents around the country use baby wipes on their infants and young toddlers many times a day, never suspecting that these products may be unsanitary or unsafe for use on a babys or childs skin. We have been using water wipes for about a year now and we have not had any problems or infections as a result of using them on our children. It hasnt. Those components were dried grapefruit seed/pulp, vegetable glycerin, and ascorbic acid. When benzene cause your bone marrow to produce abnormal cells, the result can be leukemia. We used them for several weeks while we waited for his fungal infection to clear up. Please, refer to the list here: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/, Consumer Safety Advocate & Manufacturer Advisor For Ingredient Safety. Ben Poston of the Journal Sentinel staff contributed to this report. The press releases provide the steps you should take if you have purchased one of the recalled items. Experts said it is very unusual to ship a product before receiving test results. They pull easily out of the packaging, which is easy to open and close, and the wipes are soft enough to please even the most delicate skin. "It is about as high as you can get.". Wipes Heres an October 5 tweet from the FDA about this announcement: And then about three weeks later, the FDA tweeted the following: Having unacceptable levels of benzene in hand sanitizer is not the same as having unacceptable levels of hair on your body. Our new Plastic-Free Original wipes are the same formula and purity as before, with just 2 ingredients: 99.9% ultra-purified water and a drop of fruit extract to naturally cleanse the skin. Amazon Elements 7. The company notified the agency it was recalling 18 brands of wipes, including Wal-Mart's Equate and Roundy's Baby Wipes, because of possible contamination withEnterobacter gergoviae, a bacterium experts said is associated with fecal matter. "Wet wipes are not well-regulated, which has shown itself to be a problem as they are difficult to preserve as a product and difficult to manufacture in a sanitary manner," said Scott Sutton, a New York-based microbiologist who has worked as a consultant to cosmetic manufacturers for 25 years. Rascal + Friends 5. Water Wipes are the ONLY ones that dont cause a rash on my daughter. All infections were traced to a contaminated baby shampoo. So thus far we continue to use them. By the way, WaterWipes baby wipes do not contain any cleansing agents. Recalled 351) and misbranded under Section 502 of the FDCA (21 U.S.C. The Sheboygan plant added baby wipe production in the 1990s and now has 700 workers. She doesnt scream like other wipes with a rash, and I noticed doesnt get as red. Using water and a wipe might work sufficiently if the baby peed only. We have been using these wipes for almost 2 years with our son, and they have been great for us. The inspector also failed to note customers had complained about foreign objects in the wipes. There also were reports of rashes and infections possibly due to the wipes. Suite 317, You can withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the unsubscribe button in emails that you receive. And he said the plant's use of tap water and its policy to ship before receiving test results were accepted industry practices, despite what the experts told the Journal Sentinel. Hazard: Fire, Burn, or Electrical Shock. recall But I cant afford to test the baby wipes on my son to bring the results to the publics attention. Never had any mold or bacteria problem and no rash. This post may contain affiliate links. I feel there is no wipe lie this . All hand sanitizers are not the same. That bacterium threatens people with compromised immune systems, is antibiotic-resistant and can live even in alcohol solutions, according to Dave Warshauer, chief bacteriologist at the Wisconsin State Laboratory of Hygiene. bought any of these disposable wipes, throw them The result of electrolysing water with a saline solution is sodium hydroxide and hypochlorous acid. This is a BETA experience. Back in 2014, when I was putting together the first edition of the Baby Wipes Rating List, I looked into the safety claims of WaterWipes baby wipes. I use these wipes to remove makeup, but have noticed that the ingredients list has changed and they now dry and irritate my skin. Snopes is aware of online reports claiming that baby wipes made by Parent's Choice, a brand operated by Walmart, were recalled in April 2022 amid unconfirmed rumors of heavy metal and arsenic exposure. "It was either manufactured filthy or it is inadequately preserved and allowed low numbers of microorganisms to grow to unacceptable levels.". I have been really happy so far, and havent had any issues. Ralph Rudolph, the company's founder, told executives to spend whatever money they had to, "as long as we find the 'mole,' " according to an email sent to Wilson, one of the whistleblowers. Rockline has not alerted the public about the latest recall. The Costco ones are like $19 for 900 wipes. If you are using them now and would like to replace them with a safer brand, there are options for you. WebThe recalled products are labeled with the UPC Code 0 41260 37597 2 and the plant code 51-4140. "I am damn proud of what we do here. If you are looking for different wipes to use, you might want to check my analysis and rating list of all major disposable baby wipes. I have been using these on myself post c-section and could figure out what was making my vagina feel like I just applied peppermint. You can withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the unsubscribe button in emails that you receive. What You Need to Know About Huggies Baby Wipes, https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/dry-baby-wipes-safe-for-your-baby/, https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/, How To Clean Your House Without Chemicals. Under Arkansas law, he was not allowed to sue for punitive damages. Its true though that its a bit of a hassle to get just one out. As it follows from our post, WaterWipes baby wipes contain benzalkonium chloride. Soap and water can be much more effective at washing off nasty microbes. Ive been using the weleda diaper cream and it doesnt seem to be working. Really appreciate your thoughts on this and love your info. This is what I learned in 2014. I have even taken them to daycare for them to use on him. Currently, specific numbers of the products are being removed from shelves after people reported that infants were dealing with respiratory issues after using the wipes. We never had a single problem with diaper rash until I brought him home and started using store-bought wipes; even with the sensitive skin ones it was just awful. Wipes Recalled WebThe recall is limited to specific lots of Cottonelle Flushable Wipes and Cottonelle GentlePlus Flushable Wipes manufactured between February 7, 2020 September 14, 2020. These complaints were from October 2014. Thanks. WebPackage recycling varies across the different materials used. The plant made moist towelettes and baby wipes for private label customers. I have been using water wipes for over 2 years with no problem. My doctor said was a great move to use these while she still has a rash. I then emailed the company and they said because the wipes are made in a very clean room they sometimes take on the smell of the disinfectant (or something) and that the smell should subside. FDA manuals suggest examining cosmetic firms that make "high-risk" products such as those used on infants, because they pose "the greatest potential health hazard if they become contaminated with bacteria.". In addition, they said that there was no food in the wipes for germs to grow, even after the opening of the pack. Wish they would be honest with the process some kids react to even small amounts of chlorine. On October 4, the FDA announced that they had found unacceptable levels of benzene, acetaldehyde, and acetal contaminants in samples of the ArtNaturals scent-free hand sanitizer. I confirm that I am over 16 years old and that I have reviewed and agree to the Terms and Conditions and have reviewed the Privacy Policy. Please keep us updated. Therefore, its not surprising that there havent been any reports of adverse events yet from use of the recalled ArtNaturals products. Now I see they were recalled yesterday! Thank you for the question! Although it doesnt pose a medical risk to healthy people, it can cause serious health complications or bacterial infections for those with But on the other hand, this additional ingredient raises concerns. While this study identified benzethonium chloride in commercial grapefruit seed extracts, this one found benzalkonium chloride in GSE. You must respect the instructions on the packet and you will have no problem, even on sensitive skin. Do you have any information on their? Over 15 years, the Arkansas plant expanded from a $5 million-a-year operation to one that brought in more than $150 million in revenue, according to court documents. Don't subscribe 30 Apr. While I dont use these wipes, I do remember coming across them and considering them in my search for good disposable wipes (we use Jackson Reece unscented)! UPC : 078742206356. Hi, Natalie: every year I decipher each ingredient of numerous baby wipes including Honest wipes: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/best-baby-wipes-rating-list-ebook/ Thank you for asking. In this study researchers examined the antimicrobial efficacy and the content of preservative agents of six commercially available grapefruit seed extracts. The Miami Herald did report on May 4 that at least 18 lots of the wipes were pulled by the box retailer for an unannounced reason. It was full of nappies and waster wipes and Im assuming they are too wet and also maybe in there longer than a week as its a big bin. Hi, do you know if the Honest baby wipes are ok? Understanding and protecting premature babys skin, WaterWipes Announces 2022 Pure Foundation Fund Winner, Changing Diapers and Understanding Babys Stool, your baby registry checklist guide: must haves for baby, plus hints and tips from other parents, advice from a midwife mom: birth and the fourth trimester. Can you be 100% sure that none of the waste gets on your hands, and they remain sterile? However, the only public notice of the current recall has been an item buried deep in the FDA website. It was listed in Rockline's internal lab results - which the inspector could not copy. Madison Dapcevich is a former writer for Snopes. Im wondering if its the wipes?! The company eventually expanded to six plants - four in the United States, one in China and one in England - and raced to the forefront of a billion-dollar industry. Were Several Brands of Baby Wipes Recalled Its typically found in crude oil, volcanoes, forest fires, and cigarette smoke. I have been using them for more than 3 years now and really love them and dont know which other one I would have used if they were proved to be nasty as well! That kind of defiance has landed other companies in trouble with the FDA, according to Marcia Crosse, head of health care for the General Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress. WebA list of 63 baby wipes with ratings from the safest to the least safe. Very worried. This material may not be reproduced without permission. You have JavaScript disabled in your browser. Melissa. while researching Water Wipes, I found out not only about the Benzalkonium Chloride (which WW now acknowledge but still dont put on the packaging) but also that the water they use is activated.